COMMENTARY : A Way to Get Out of Seventh
- Share via
Major league baseball officials, planning their future this year in the lull between seasons, have a chance to strengthen their game with a break with tradition.
Some of them even mentioned such a break during the World Series. The suggestion: Three divisions, rather than two, in each league.
They could reorganize as soon as next season, when the Colorado Rockies and Florida Marlins join the National League, making it a 14-team league, same as the American.
The plan at the moment is for the National to split into two seven-team divisions, same as the American, next April.
But in the crowded sports environment, seven-team divisions are too large and unwieldy.
In any such league, there will always be six losers and one winner in each division. That’s a dozen losers--too many.
To plan that kind of league, deliberately, is to make an obvious error in an era when:
--Reduced TV income for baseball seems just ahead.
--Basketball, football and other sports continue to grow, sometimes at baseball’s expense.
Shouldn’t baseball have, as a central objective in any restructuring, more baseball interest nationwide?
If so, one way to get it is with three-division leagues replacing the game’s cumbersome, loser-heavy Easts and Wests.
A three-division realignment would guarantee, for each league, three championship races annually, instead of two; three winners, instead of two; three runners-up, instead of two; and nobody in seventh place.
It would also guarantee more postseason interest.
With a nucleus of six division champions instead of four, the playoffs could be rearranged in any one of several attractive ways.
If baseball had a three-division alignment in each league, what would be lost?
--Some old rivalries perhaps?
Yes, but. . . . In all sports--baseball among them--new rivalries tend to rise easily and spontaneously, particularly in old, established major league cities such as Chicago, where Bear fans, for example, have learned to love to hate Minnesota.
--Some TV commitments?
Yes, but. . . . When they really think it over, most TV executives, along with most baseball fans, would doubtless prefer six races a year in the big leagues to four, leading to more competition, more excitement and more revenue.
--Some scheduling preferences?
Yes, but. . . . Scheduling problems of any kind are surely a second consideration to more pennant races and the prospect of closer pennant races, promoting more national interest and creating more revenue.
--Numerically uneven divisions?
Yes, but. . . :
--In the first place, uneven divisions would give the columnists and talk shows something to talk about, meaning they would be talking about baseball. Thus, a plus for baseball.
--Second, uneven divisions are basically irrelevant. In the NFL, which has them, expansion is sometimes discussed, but never urgently.
For baseball, realignment ought to be a question of priorities.
And the first priority seems abundantly clear: ridding baseball of all those losers in seven-team divisions.
How Baseball Could Realign
Of the many ways in which major league baseball could be realigned, one is geographical:
NATIONAL LEAGUE
IF GIANTS MOVE TO FLORIDA
* EAST: Atlanta Braves, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies, St. Petersburg Giants, Florida Marlins.
* MIDWEST: Pittsburgh Pirates, Montreal Expos, Cincinnati Reds, St. Louis Cardinals, Chicago Cubs.
* WEST: San Diego Padres, Houston Astros, Dodgers, Colorado Rockies.
NATIONAL LEAGUE
IF GIANTS STAY IN CALIFORNIA
* EAST: Atlanta Braves, Montreal Expos, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies, Florida Marlins.
* MIDWEST: Pittsburgh Pirates, Cincinnati Reds, St. Louis Cardinals, Chicago Cubs.
* WEST: San Diego Padres, Houston Astros, San Francisco Giants, Dodgers, Colorado Rockies.
AMERICAN LEAGUE
* ATLANTIC: Toronto Blue Jays, Baltimore Orioles, New York Yankees, Detroit Tigers, Boston Red Sox.
* CENTRAL: Milwaukee Brewers, Minnesota Twins, Chicago White Sox, Kansas City Royals, Cleveland Indians.
* PACIFIC: Oakland Athletics, Texas Rangers, Angels, Seattle Mariners.
More to Read
Go beyond the scoreboard
Get the latest on L.A.'s teams in the daily Sports Report newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.