No clear mayoral favorites
Lolita Harper
The title of mayor is one that holds more notoriety than power and is
usually passed from council member to council member with the quick
searing pain of tearing a bandage from a wound. Tonight, the council
will vote in its new leader: Let the ripping begin.
Costa Mesa Mayor Gary Monahan will relinquish his seat to the next
director in a process that simply requires a majority of the five
council members to vote a colleague to the largely ceremonial
position. While on paper, the procedure looks black and white, the
politics behind the vote are largely gray.
Which might explain why nobody can answer who will most likely be
the next mayor.
“I don’t know,” Monahan said. “[Councilman] Chris Steel obviously
likes surprises, so we might have a surprise.”
The mayor was referring to last year’s mayoral selection, in which
all conventional guesses put Monahan at the helm of the City Council.
A surprising move by Steel and Councilwomen Libby Cowan and Karen
Robinson invalidated that notion by casting their support for
Robinson, and voting Steel as mayor pro tem.
When Robinson abandoned her council position for a judgeship, the
position was again up for grabs. Monahan regained what was long
thought to be rightfully his, putting an end to the drama.
But it is that time of year again. Steel is the mayor pro tem, who
traditionally steps into the mayor’s spot, but neither he nor Monahan
see that happening.
Steel said he has no idea who will end up in the mayor’s seat and
said he has made no calls or overtures about it.
“It’s up to my colleagues to nominate and elect,” Steel said. “If
they chose me, I will do a good job to improve the schools, lower the
crime rate and resolve the growing unabated conditions in the city.
... But I am only one of four votes. And those four votes have a
history of choosing to continue the status quo, woe, flow. So, I
don’t expect to be mayor.”
Putting politics aside, Monahan said he would not support Steel
because he “is not ready,” leaving a short list of those who are.
“[Councilman] Mike Scheafer is brand new and [Councilman] Allan
Mansoor is a good kid,” Monahan said.
That leaves either Monahan or Cowan to lead the council, both of
whom have already served as mayor. Monahan would not confirm or deny
if he would seek the support of his colleagues for his third term as
mayor.
“I don’t know what will happen,” the mayor said. “Let’s just say I
would be honored to serve another year and I am prepared. But it
would not be the end of the world either way.”
* LOLITA HARPER writes columns Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays.
She may be reached at (949) 574-4275 or by e-mail at
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.